Top 50 Prospect Profile: #39 Phil Avlas

Phil Avlas might not be the top catcher in the Diamondbacks system, but he's the top receiver in the Diamondbacks system. Up the middle defense counts, and you don't get any more in the middle of baseball than being a catcher. In a FREE PREVIEW OF PREMIUM CONTENT FutureBacks breaks down #39 in the FutureBacks Fifty, Phil Avlas.


Name: Phil Avlas

Position: Catcher

DOB: 12/17/1982

Height: 5'11"

Weight:  183lbs

Bats/Throws:  R/R

Last season was not Phil Avlas' favorite in pro ball.  He started the year in Double-A Tennessee, only to find himself spitting time with two other catching prospects.  The inconsistency hurt him, and then an injury hurt him even more.  After missing more than a month Avlas was ready to come off the disabled list, but by that time the Diamondbacks wanted to take a look at Miguel Montero in Double-A.  Avlas was demoted back to Lancaster, and took his frustrations out on California League pitching. 

He hit .367 with five homers and 24 RBI in 37 games with the JetHawks, while Montero stumbled in Double-A.  He'll have to battle with the younger Montero next season for a spot in Double-A, but this is not a catcher whose time has past.

"He's so good defensively, and so good at handling pitchers, that even if he couldn't hit at all he'd be a commodity," FutureBacks' David Merchant says, "but he can hit, and has gotten stronger, so he doesn't get tied up on inside fastballs as often.  Montero may  be the hot prospect right now, but Avlas has value."

Batting and Power:  Avlas has never been a big power producer, and when he's tried to, it's hurt his strikeout numbers.  He's a gap hitter who, when he's right, will put the bat on the ball and hit for average.  He's shown problems in his first chance at moving up, often taking half a season or so to adjust.  That bodes well for a return trip to Double-A next season, where he hit only .239 in 41 games. 

He's looking to add muscle in the offseason, not necessarily to hit the ball out of the park, but to avoid getting jammed on good fastballs inside, something that had started happening to him in 2004 at Hi-A.  If he can hit .260 in the big leagues, he could very easily become a Brad Ausmus type catcher, so good with the glove and the head that anything he does with the bat becomes a bonus.

Baserunning and Speed:  He's a catcher, which means two things, he doesn't run often, and when he does he's almost always picking on a pitcher who isn't paying attention and making it, or getting thrown out when the batter couldn't keep up his end of the 'hit and run' bargain.  On the bases he's smart, but far from conservative, taking advantage of lazy outfielders who assume he won't take the extra base because he is a catcher.

Defense:  Is the name of the game.  Though his arm is just barely above average, he's very accurate, and gets rid of the ball quickly, allowing him to cut down more than his share of runners.   His real talent though lies in handling a pitching staff and calling games, something he's drawn praise for since he came in the league.  His Manager at Hi-A last year was a former catcher, Bill Plummer, and Plummer called him one of his favorite players.

"He's such a luxury for a coach," a scout said, "because he just knows what to do in every situation.  You watch games and he almost never looks into the dugout for a sign, because he knows what the manager wants the infield to do, what pitch he wants called, where he wants it.  The kid's s true student of the game."

Prediction:  Avlas will have to prove he can hit at a high level before he will be considered an elite catching prospect, but he very well could make the show as a defensive minded backup quickly.  If the Diamondbacks find themselves in a position where they needed a catcher right away, it seems likely Avlas would get the call ahead of Montero, because even if he doesn't necessarily give you a lot with the bat, he will hold and handle his own behind the plate.

"I loved working with him," a pitcher said after the 2005 Arizona Fall League, where Avlas was a mid season replacement for Montero, "because even in the bullpen, when Phil wasn't even in the game, he was working with you, talking about spotting pitches, picking things up in your delivery, just a really smart player, a guy who makes it easy to pitch."

ETA:  Injuries are probably Avlas' best bet of making the show, but a solid year in Double-A couldn't hurt.  Currently the Diamondbacks pecking order at catcher goes Chris Snyder, Koyie Hill, Miguel Montero and then Avlas, but both Montero and Avlas could move ahead of Hill this season if the switch hitting former Dodger doesn't show vast improvement soon.  Expect Avlas to bounce back and forth in an injury situation in '07.

Agree?  Disagree?  Tell us what you think by emailing Managing Editor James Renwick at if your question, comment, or concern is chosen for our weekly 'Fire D'Back' segment, beginning Saturday, December 3rd, you'll win a one month subscription to

Want to get the details on the Top 50 Prospects and all the Individual Scouting reports that will be coming up over the next several months? Sign up today for's Total Access Pass, which will give you access to all the information you crave. Only $79.95 for a one full year subscription of the Total Access Pass, gives you access to all premium content on, Scout™ Player and Roster Database (including the 'Hot News' at the top of the site), Breaking News and Information. You also receive Total Access to ALL Websites, and Player Pages. That includes all baseball, football, college football and college basketball sites on the network. Don't feel comfortable with a year subscription? FutureBacks offers you monthly and three-month subscriptions for only $7.95 and $21.95 respectively. Recommended Stories

  • Peyton Manning emerged alone atop yet another category in the NFL record book tonight vs the Niners, as he tossed touchdown #509 under the national spotlight of Sunday Night Football (NBC). (Photo…

  • Former USC and NFL running back LenDale White added tons of drama to what was a relatively quiet Homecoming weekend for the Trojans.

  • Here’s a way to watch football and improve your golf swing at the same time. In your living room (or on the range), practice the one-minute golf swing, as shown in this video. Set the timer on your…

  • Dr. Roto, like many others, can't believe Seattle Seahawks QB Russell Wilson (pictured above) passed for over 300 yards and rushed for over 100 yards in the same game. First time that's ever happened…

  • As soon as those winds fall off, get into the stand! I always tell people you can't kill them if you aren't out, but if you want to try and pick an opportune time – this is it.

Up Next


1 Fans online
    Join The Conversation